Search Results

Title: Mid-Life Health Consequences of Crime and Punishment
Resulting in 1 citation.
1. Massoglia, Michael
Mid-Life Health Consequences of Crime and Punishment
Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Minnesota, December 2005
Cohort(s): NLSY79
Publisher: ProQuest Dissertations & Theses (PQDT)
Keyword(s): Health Factors; Health, Mental/Psychological; Heterogeneity; Incarceration/Jail; Modeling; Punishment, Criminal; Racial Differences

Permission to reprint the abstract has not been received from the publisher.

This dissertation has two basic aims. First, it examines the relationship between incarceration and mid-life mental and physical health functioning. Next, it considers whether the penal system contributes to racial health disparities. The conceptual and analytical models of health functioning are drawn from various theoretical traditions, including criminology, medical and life course sociology, and social stratification. Data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth are used to estimate (1) correlational models establishing baseline incarceration effects on mental and physical health, (2) regression models assessing the effect of incarceration on mental and physical health, (3) regression models assessing the impact of incarceration on racial inequalities in physical health, and (4) propensity score models of the treatment effect of incarceration on mental and physical health.

Three main findings emerge from the analysis. First, incarceration is a powerful predictor of mid-life mental and physical health functioning. Second, these effects are evident in models that account for the non-random nature of incarceration. That is, even when models are employed to correct for sample heterogeneity, the significant physical and mental health effects remain. Finally, the results indicate that incarceration contributes to racial inequalities in physical health. When incarceration is included in models estimating physical health functioning, racial differences in health become non-significant.

A variety of factors come together to explain these findings. First, incarceration fractures social bonds associated with health functioning. Additionally, incarceration lowers the likelihood of gainful wages and depresses wages. Furthermore, incarceration exposes individuals to high levels of infectious diseases and stress. Finally, most ex-inmates find themselves near the bottom of the social hierarchy, making it difficult for them to fully control their lives and participate in society upon release.

These factors, with two additional considerations, also explain how incarceration contributes to racial inequalities in physical health. First, relative to whites, blacks are much more likely to be incarcerated and, therefore, more likely to be exposed to the negative health effects of the penal system. Second, it appears more difficult for blacks than whites to reestablish social bonds to social institutions that protect or enhance physical health.

Bibliography Citation
Massoglia, Michael. Mid-Life Health Consequences of Crime and Punishment. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Minnesota, December 2005.